Agile panel debate at OOPSLA

October 27, 2006


I attended a panel debate at OOPSLA on agile methodologies. A lot of insightful information was given by the panelists (including Alistair Cockburn, Dave Thomas, Jutta Eckstein, Randy Miller, and Mark Striebeck) derived from their experiences in the field.
One question to the panel was on how to introduce agile in a large corporation which relies heavily on the waterfall approach and that was unwilling to change? One argument (from Dave Thomas) was that the development team could start focusing on continuous integration, testing, and perhaps test-driven development. As the code handed over to the QA department would have a higher quality, the role of the QA department decrease, and a more agile model would occur. Jutta Eckstein pointed out that as long as you have no by-in from the management, you will not get the value proposition from agile, but you could still use some of the agile tools.
Another important topic that came up how one could be agile when faced with usability issues (and I think, user interface design). It was pointed out that experience was that user interface development had to be started before the (implementation) iterations. There was some controversy in the panel on this issue, but one point that was made that the iterations should not focus on delivery to the customer, but should focus on end-usage of the system, in which user interface design and usability are important components.
What is the greatest advance in agile practices in the last 5 years? What new things should we teach our students? To this question, Dave Thomas replied that the most important thing is testing; unit testing and acceptancy testing. I very much agree to this, and I feel that we still have a long way to go, especially on acceptancy testing.
All in all, the panel discussion touched on many very interesting topics:

  • Everything should go in the backlog (Dave Thomas). Projects tend to keep things out of the backlog, making them lose overview and large variations in velocity. Things like vacations and defect stories should go in the backlog. Management should have a backlog, too, consisting of things like risks.
  • Focus more on deliverables (Alistair Cockburn). Focus on deliverables are key to agile processes, not iteration planning, iterations, and velocity. If you have the three latter without the focus on the former, you are not going agile.
  • There is no ideal iteration length. Iteration length varies from project to project. There have been teams (advanced!) that focus on continuous delivery with no iterations. The most important is to have short feedback loops.
  • Pair programming (Dave Thomas). Pair programming is four eyes looking at the code at some time, it does not mean two hands holding the mouse

Profile picture

Written by Vidar Kongsli who is a software professional living in Oslo, Norway. Works as a consultant, system architect and developer at Bredvid. You should follow him on Twitter